Jake Stahl is one of just 11 Red Sox players to have won AL home run titles. He performed the feat way back in 1910, during the Deadball Era, which helps explain why Stahl’s 10 home runs were enough to lead both leagues. He’s also one of just six Red Sox managers to win a World Championship with Boston.
A native of Elkhart, IL, Stahl starred in both baseball and football for the University of Illinois before making his big league debut with the Red Sox as a backup catcher with the 1903 team. Boston then sold him to the Washington Nationals where Stahl was immediately inserted as that team’s starting first baseman. At the time, the Washington franchise was barely surviving and being run by AL President Ban Johnson until new ownership could be found. Johnson liked the college-educated Stahl so much, he made him the team’s player manager in 1905. Though he had some early success in that role, the team then faltered and Stahl was traded to the White Sox in 1906. By then he had married a girl he met in college, who had a wealthy businessman for a father and Stahl had started a second career in the banking business. He probably would have retired from baseball then and there except for the fact that he was traded back to the Red Sox in 1908.
He put together three solid seasons as Boston’s starting first baseman but was faced with a career dilemma. He was doing much better financially with his banking career than he was playing baseball and he knew the wise personal decision was to quit the game and devote himself full time to the financial industry. That’s what he did after the 1910 season.
Then in 1911, he was approached by the Red Sox with an offer to become player-manager of the team and a co-owner of the franchise. He accepted and led the 1912 Red Sox to an AL Pennant and a World Series victory over the New York Giants. Stahl started at first base for that ball club and hit a career high .301. The success didn’t last. By the following season he was done as a player and after quarreling with the team’s other owners over how the club was being run, he quit and went back to his banking career. Unfortunately, he pretty much worked himself to death, suffering a nervous breakdown in 1920 and then dying in a California tuberculosis sanitarium two years later, at the age of 43.
The six Red Sox managers who won World Championships with the club are: Jimmy Collins, Stahl, Bill Carrigan (twice), Ed Barrow, Terry Francona (twice) and John Farrell. Here is a list of Boston’s AL Home Run champions